> This page is from **SQOUT** by QuDef — https://sqout.qudef.com/
>
> SQOUT, by QuDef, is a security intelligence and knowledge framework for quantum technologies. Its catalogue describes attacks, vulnerabilities, countermeasures and security proofs for quantum communication and quantum computing systems.
>
> How to use and cite this content: https://sqout.qudef.com/llms.txt

# Frequency-Shift Attack (A-0057)

Source: https://sqout.qudef.com/technique/A-0057
Cite as: SQOUT (QuDef), https://sqout.qudef.com/technique/A-0057, A-0057

- **QID:** A-0057
- **UUID:** 23a50eb3-24a5-4a57-a8a2-1380f7a1bce3
- **Type:** Quantum
- **Domain(s):** Quantum Communication
- **Tactic:** Execution
- **Updated:** 2026-11-11
- **Maturity:** Theoretical

## Description

The Frequency-Shift Attack is a sophisticated strategy where the threat actor (Eve) replaces the receiver's (Bob's) optical pulses with time-shifted ones - in the two-way QKD scheme, aiming to modulate these pulses at the rising edge of the transmitter's (Alice's) phase modulator. This manipulation results in a frequency shift of Alice's signals that correlates with the selected quantum state, enabling Eve to decipher the key by simply analyzing the frequency of the returned signals.

**Update ([Jiang2014]):** The manoeuvre is possible only because Alice does not check when the signal and reference pulses arrive, a loophole the source names explicitly and shares with the phase-remapping attack, so closing it defeats both. The attack remains a theoretical proposal: [Jiang2014] is an analysis with no experiment, and it assumes, rather than shows, that Eve can resolve the frequency difference.

## Technique-Countermeasures

- CM-0016 State Preparation Monitoring <https://sqout.qudef.com/countermeasure/CM-0016>
- CM-0027 Arrival Time Monitoring <https://sqout.qudef.com/countermeasure/CM-0027>
- CM-0011 Watchdog Detector <https://sqout.qudef.com/countermeasure/CM-0011>
- CM-0014 Full Device Imperfections Incorporation in Scientific Security Proof <https://sqout.qudef.com/countermeasure/CM-0014>

## Technique-Layer Mappings

- CAT-0501 Electronics & Analog Components
- CAT-0500 Physical Layer (Quantum & Optical)

## Related Techniques

- A-0054 Phase-Remapping Attack <https://sqout.qudef.com/technique/A-0054>

## Techniques Relating to This One

- A-0088 Frequency Side Channel Attack in Twin-Field QKD <https://sqout.qudef.com/technique/A-0088>
- A-0067 Wavelength-Selected Photon-Number-Splitting Attack <https://sqout.qudef.com/technique/A-0067>

## Literature

- [ETSI016PP] Quantum Key Distribution (QKD); Common Criteria Protection Profile - Pair of Prepare and Measure Quantum Key Distribution Modules <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/ETSI016PP>
- [Fung2007] Phase-remapping attack in practical quantum-key-distribution systems <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/Fung2007>
- [Huang2026a] Frequency domain side channel on lithium niobate phase modulator in high-rate quantum key distribution system <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/Huang2026a>
- [ISOIEC23837P1] ISO/IEC DIS 23837-1:2022 Information security - Security requirements, test and evaluation methods for quantum key distribution - Part 1: Requirements <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/ISOIEC23837P1>
- [Jiang2014] Frequency shift attack on plug-and-play quantum key distribution systems <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/Jiang2014>
- [Jiang2025] Effect of frequency side channels on the security of practical quantum key distribution <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/Jiang2025>
- [Lu2021] Practical analysis of sending or not-sending twin-field quantum key distribution with frequency side channels <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/Lu2021>
- [Qi2021] Loophole-free plug-and-play quantum key distribution <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/Qi2021>
- [Shor2000] Simple proof of security of the BB84 quantum key distribution protocol <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/Shor2000>
- [Xu2010] Experimental demonstration of phase-remapping attack in a practical quantum key distribution system <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/Xu2010>
- [Xu2020] Secure quantum key distribution with realistic devices <https://sqout.qudef.com/literature/Xu2020>

